SEO for Insurance Agents: A How-To Guide
By: Ananyaa Venkat | Updated On: February 6, 2025
Table of Contents
Are you finding it difficult to attract new clients for your insurance agency despite providing genuine services? You are not alone.
Insurance is a highly competitive industry and you need to establish your presence in places where people are looking for insurance service providers like you. That’s how you can acquire more insurance clients.
Nearly 70% of insurance shoppers run an online search before scheduling an appointment with an insurance agency.
That means if you aren’t showing up online for insurance-based searches, you are losing close to 70% of the opportunities.
So, how do you make your agency show up on Google and other search engines? Enter SEO for insurance agents.
In this guide, I’ll tell you how you can leverage SEO strategies to boost the visibility of your insurance company.
Why Insurance Agencies Need SEO
Here are the specific reasons why SEO is a must-have for your insurance company.
Improved Online Visibility
Insurance companies should rank higher in search to be quickly found by their prospective clients. Leveraging SEO for insurance brokers can help you increase online visibility for insurance-related searches.
Increased Organic Traffic
By boosting your online discoverability, SEO helps you drive more traffic to your insurance website organically. These visitors are your leads that can be translated into insurance clients.
Increased Trust and Brand Credibility
Google has strict E-E-A-T for YMYL sites, including insurance. SEO allows you to raise your E-E-A-T standards and build trust in the eyes of users and Google alike.
How to Do SEO for Insurance Companies: 10 Proven Strategies
Now that you know the importance of SEO for insurance agencies, let’s start discussing the strategies you need to implement for SEO success.
1. Audit Your Website
Auditing your website helps you find potential issues with it. Finding those lurking problems is the first step to creating a customized SEO strategy for your insurance company.
In fact, that’s how we were able to identify toxic backlinks hindering the SEO growth of our insurance agency client, FCA Insurance Brokers.
Following the disavowal there was naturally a dip in the number of websites linking back to our client. But that was for a short while. We started building more relevant backlinks to their site from trusted niche sites and the number of referring domains were steadily increasing since then.
You can also build a healthy website and see it exhibit similar growth. Again, a meticulous site audit lays the foundation for that to happen.
2. Perform Keyword Research
Focused keyword research is essential to shortlist keywords people use to search for insurance-related information online. These are the keywords you want to rank for to boost your online visibility.
Let’s take FCA Insurance, for example.
The choice of keywords was one of the on-page issues we spotted on our client’s website. We did an in-depth audience research and found keywords matching the real intent of the website. We placed them naturally in their content. Now, they are ranking for 3400 intent-specific keywords. (which was previously just close to 1600). That’s 2X growth in keyword rankings for our client.
When you choose your keywords, make sure they have a good search volume and match the user’s search intent.
3. Optimize Meta Tags
Meta titles and descriptions are one of the first things the user gets to see when your web pages appear in search results.
In fact, FCA Insurance showcased significant improvement in intent-focused keyword rankings after optimizing meta tags. See the keyword rankings by intent visibly going up in the graph below.
You can do it too.
Make sure you write genuinely compelling meta descriptions and infuse intent-specific keywords naturally into your headings and meta tags to boost your SERP appearance for insurance-focused searches.
4. Create Industry-Specific Helpful Content
As the famous saying goes, Content is King. This is true for the insurance industry as well.
Google loves content that is relevant and helpful to the users. Plus, with insurance coming under the YMYL category, you can use your content to showcase your industry expertise and experience to establish authority and trustworthiness.
That’s why we suggested FCA Insurance Brokers publish high-quality blog articles under the name of their insurance experts with credible author bios vouching for their industry expertise. Additionally, we bridged the gaps in their existing content based on the audit.
Their blogs now hold the first 3 positions in the list of their top-performing pages.
5. Build a Robust Internal Linking Structure
Google discovers new pages on the internet often by crawling links within the web pages it has already crawled and indexed.
That’s why it’s important to link new pages on your insurance website to relevant, existing internal pages.
For FCA Insurance, We interlinked their internal content pages to build a robust internal linking structure and improve the probability of the website users visiting relevant money-making pages. Now, they have a strong internal linking architecture with 14,000+ internal links.
When you build internal backlinks, make sure you choose the right anchor texts to tell Google and users what the new page is about.
This will let Google see how topically relevant your pages are and vouch for your expertise in the insurance niche.
6. Implement Schema Markup
Implementing schema markup is a great way to improve the visibility of your insurance website in SERPs.
By adding structured data to your pages, you can provide Google with more context about your content so that the search engine will rank you higher.
In fact, proper implementation of schema markup was one of our on-page SEO recommendations for FCA insurance to boost their appearance in Rich Snippets, which show up above the traditional Google Search results.
7. Optimize Your Google Business Profile
Local SEO plays a vital role in improving the online visibility of your insurance agency, especially if you want to attract clients in specific geographic locations.
By creating and optimizing your Google Business Profile (GBP), you increase the chances of appearing in Google’s local search features like Google Maps and Local-3-Pack.
Ensure that your business name, address, and phone number (NAP) are accurate and consistent on GBP and other local directories.
8. Maintain a Good Online Reputation
Reviews and testimonials play a critical role in establishing your credibility, especially in the insurance sector, where clients are often cautious about whom they choose for their financial security needs.
Positive reviews from satisfied clients serve as powerful social proof. They vouch for your agency’s quality of services and reliability to your prospective clients.
On the other hand, negative reviews can happen to even the best businesses, but how you respond to them is what truly matters.
In such situations, ensure that you address the pain point that caused the negative review rather than defending your actions blatantly.
A well-handled response can turn a negative situation into an opportunity to demonstrate professionalism and commitment to client satisfaction.
9. Build Backlinks From Relevant Websites
Backlinks remain one of the most critical factors in establishing authority and improving search engine rankings for insurance websites.
You need to acquire backlinks from high-authority, niche-relevant websites, like finance blogs, insurance portals, and industry news sites to your website.
Take FCA Insurance, for instance, From 114 referring domains in December 2021, they now have 480+ relevant domains linking back to them. Over 320 of those referring domains have a Domain Authority of 30 or higher.
Your website can attract such high-quality backlinks too. Guest posting, claiming unlinked brand mentions and offering your content as a replacement for broken links on other insurance websites are some of the proven ways to build relevant backlinks.
10. Measure SEO Performance
SEO isn’t a one-and-done process. It requires consistent monitoring and adjustments to ensure long-term success.
Tracking key SEO metrics like organic traffic, keyword rankings, and Domain Authority of your website is essential to evaluate the effectiveness of your insurance SEO strategies.
Take FCA Insurance, for instance. With a data-driven approach, we monitored their SEO performance consistently and refined their strategy. Here’s what the results looked like:
- Organic Traffic grew from 738 monthly visits to over 3400+ visits. That’s a 4X boost.
- Domain Authority improved from 23 to 37, indicating stronger authority and trust in the eyes of search engines.
You can use tools like Ahrefs or Semrush to monitor these metrics for your website. If you see an increase in these numbers, your strategy is working. If not, it means your insurance SEO strategy needs tweaking.
Leveraging the right insurance SEO strategies is key to boosting your online visibility and search rankings. The higher your agency ranks, the more your chances of magnetizing insurance shoppers.Need help creating a future-proof SEO strategy for your insurance agency? Book a free consultation call with Stan Ventures to get started.
Get Your Free SEO Audit Now!
Enter your website URL below to receive a comprehensive SEO report with tailored insights to boost your site's visibility and rankings.
You May Also Like
SEO for Universities and Colleges: A Complete Guide in 2025
Students search for the best universities to pursue higher education, and with internet technologies flourishing, Google has become the go-to source to filter the top-ranking universities.
SaaS SEO: How to Build a Winning SEO Strategy for Your SaaS Business
With at least 70% of leading B2B (business to business) buyers kicking off their search for the best companies to buy from with a search query on Google or other search engines
SEO for Locksmiths: Best Tips and Tricks to Rank #1 on Google
Some of the best locksmith websites attribute their success to good SEO practices and dynamic digital marketing efforts.
Comments