Search Loophole? Google AI Shows Penalized Content
By: Zulekha Nishad | Updated On: January 15, 2025
Table of Contents
Did you know that even sites penalized by Google’s search algorithms can still appear in its AI-generated overviews?
This unusual phenomenon—highlighted by industry experts—reveals that pages with manual actions imposed on them, which prevent their ranking in traditional search results, can still make their way to the top of AI overview panels.
Let’s unpack how this works, its implications, and what this could mean for the future of search.
Flagged but Featured
In an unexpected twist, it has come to light that websites suffering from manual actions—Google’s penalties for violations of its search quality guidelines—are not entirely out of the game.
While invisible in Google’s organic search results, these pages can still feature in AI overview snippets displayed prominently at the top of search pages.
Lily Ray first reported this anomaly on X, noting that penalized pages affected by “Site Reputation Abuse” actions remained visible in AI overviews for weeks, even months.
This just in: pages hit by manual actions can still appear in AI Overviews, weeks/months after being demoted in organic search.
In fact, it’s been ~2 months since sites were hit by Site Reputation Abuse manual actions, and affected articles can still appear in AI Overviews 😅 pic.twitter.com/xzm9zskGvM
— Lily Ray 😏 (@lilyraynyc) January 8, 2025
Glenn Gabe corroborated this finding, providing additional examples and expressing his surprise that Google’s stringent manual actions did not completely exclude such content from AI-generated results.
Yep, this is true. Just came across another example of this happening. It’s odd, and I believe Google will address it, but for now sites with manual actions can still appear in AIOs (even when those directories have been completely deindexed). Poof, gone, but not gone. 🙂 https://t.co/C2HUpSpCec
— Glenn Gabe (@glenngabe) January 13, 2025
These revelations sparked lively discussions across digital marketing forums, leaving many professionals wondering if this was a temporary glitch, a deliberate feature, or simply a lag in how Google updates its AI datasets.
Unpacking the Why: The Mechanics of an AI Glitch
Why does this happen? The answer might lie in the asynchronous way Google’s AI overviews are updated compared to its main search index.
Historically, AI-generated summaries have shown a delayed synchronization with organic search results. This means changes to the search index, including manual actions and penalties, may not immediately reflect in AI outputs.
It’s also possible that Google’s AI systems pull data from a separate index or dataset, distinct from the one powering its main search engine.
If this dataset isn’t updated with the same rigor or frequency, penalized content might linger in AI overviews longer than intended. Another theory is that this anomaly could stem from a technical bug—a possibility that both Ray and Gabe suggested.
A Temporary Gap or a Systemic Oversight?
For now, this loophole raises questions about the integrity of AI-generated results. If penalized content can still appear in prominent positions, what does that mean for the trustworthiness of these summaries?
On one hand, this could signal a weakness in Google’s system. On the other, it might simply be a growing pain in the evolution of AI-driven search technologies.
From a user perspective, this anomaly could lead to misleading or lower-quality information appearing in AI summaries.
For marketers and site owners, it offers a perplexing opportunity: even if penalized by Google, their content might still gain visibility in AI-driven features.
However, relying on this loophole would be short-sighted, as such issues are likely to be addressed in future updates.
Google’s Dual Standards
Google’s use of AI in search has been a journey of innovation and adaptation. AI overviews, launched as part of the company’s effort to enhance user experience, aim to provide quick, concise answers derived from top-tier web content.
However, the integration of AI has not been without its hiccups.
In the past, Google’s AI systems have struggled with delayed updates, misinterpretations of content, and inaccuracies in generating summaries. This latest discovery adds to a series of challenges that underline the complexities of merging AI with traditional search methodologies.
Manual actions, introduced years ago, are designed to maintain the quality and credibility of Google’s search results.
By penalizing sites that engage in deceptive practices or violate guidelines, Google has sought to ensure a level playing field.
Yet, the apparent disconnect between these actions and AI-generated outputs reveals a gap that needs to be bridged.
What’s Next? The Road to Smarter AI Integration
If left unaddressed, this issue could have far-reaching implications. Users might lose trust in AI overviews if they realize penalized or subpar content can still appear prominently. This could erode confidence in Google’s ability to deliver reliable, high-quality results across its platforms.
For Google, this presents both a challenge and an opportunity. Fixing this problem will likely involve rethinking how AI datasets are curated and synchronized with the main search index.
It might also prompt the company to develop more robust safeguards to ensure penalized content is excluded from all search features, not just the main index.
In the long term, this could lead to significant advancements in how AI integrates with search.
Improved synchronization, better content filtering, and enhanced transparency in AI-driven features are likely outcomes as Google addresses this loophole.
Steering Clear of Shortcuts
For those in the digital marketing industry, this development serves as a reminder to prioritize quality and adhere to Google’s guidelines.
While it might be tempting to exploit this loophole, such strategies are inherently risky and unsustainable. Instead, focus on creating valuable, authentic content that aligns with best practices.
Monitor how your content performs across different search features, including AI overviews, and stay informed about updates to Google’s algorithms and policies.
Engaging in transparent, ethical practices will ensure long-term success and resilience, regardless of changes in the digital landscape.
Key Takeaways
- Pages hit with Google’s manual actions can still appear in AI-generated summaries, raising questions about system integrity.
- The issue likely stems from delays or discrepancies between Google’s main search index and its AI datasets.
- Digital marketing professionals have highlighted this anomaly, sparking widespread discussion and debate.
- Google is expected to address this loophole, improving synchronization and quality control in AI overviews.
- Marketers should prioritize high-quality, guideline-compliant content and monitor developments in AI-driven search.
Get Your Free SEO Audit Now!
Enter your website URL below to receive a comprehensive SEO report with tailored insights to boost your site's visibility and rankings.

You May Also Like
Google’s Tabbed Content Dilemma: Are You Losing SEO Rankings?
Website owners and digital marketers have long debated whether Google can effectively crawl and index tabbed content. Now, thanks to insights from John Mueller, we finally have some clarity—but it might not be what you expected. SEO expert Remy Sharp recently asked on Bluesky whether Google and other search engines could navigate JavaScript or CSS-based … Google’s Tabbed Content Dilemma: Are You Losing SEO Rankings?
Google’s Review Count Bug Leaves Businesses Frustrated
A strange bug has been affecting Google reviews since Friday, February 7th, causing widespread panic among small businesses and local SEO professionals. Many businesses woke up to find some of their hard-earned reviews missing, while others noticed significant drops in their review count. But before assuming the worst, here’s what’s actually happening. What’s Happening … Google’s Review Count Bug Leaves Businesses Frustrated
The Future of AI: Who Gains and Who Loses in the Tech Boom?
AI is no longer some futuristic concept; it’s here, and it’s moving fast. But as exciting as this is, OpenAI CEO Sam Altman has a big concern – not everyone is going to benefit equally. Some will ride the wave of AI into new opportunities, while others might find themselves left behind. Well, that’s a … The Future of AI: Who Gains and Who Loses in the Tech Boom?
Comments