Conflicting Google Results? Here’s the Surprising Reason
By: Zulekha Nishad | Updated On: November 6, 2024
Table of Contents
Ever notice how Google’s answers at the top of search results don’t always line up? Depending on how you phrase your search, Google’s Featured Snippets can actually show opposing information from the same source.
A recent study has uncovered this surprising glitch, raising concerns about whether Google is giving us helpful answers or just echoing what it thinks we want to hear.
The Problem With Google’s Snippets
Google’s Featured Snippets are supposed to provide quick, reliable information. But this study by Sarah Presch at Dragon Metrics reveals a flaw: they can display totally opposite answers from the same source, depending on how you ask.
For instance, searching “does sunscreen block vitamin D absorption?” might show you a snippet suggesting sunscreen can lower vitamin D production by blocking UVB rays.
But search “can you get vitamin D with sunscreen on?,” and you might get a snippet saying that you can still get vitamin D while wearing sunscreen.
This contradiction shows how the way we phrase a search can completely change the answer Google serves up.
The study found these inconsistencies pop up across various topics, from health to politics. And it all boils down to this: Google is focused on what it thinks you want to see, not necessarily what’s accurate or balanced.
How User Intent Is Causing Confusion
Google’s algorithm is built to “understand” what users intend by their questions and pull relevant answers. However, this focus on intent over accuracy leads to issues.
Instead of a straightforward answer, Google may try to tailor results to what it thinks you’re really asking—and sometimes it guesses wrong.
Sarah Presch calls Google’s algorithm “one big bias machine.” The way Google is designed, it tries to please users by showing them what they’re most likely to click. This can create a feedback loop: if people often click on answers that match what they already believe, Google’s algorithm will show more of that type of answer.
This becomes especially tricky with topics like health or politics, where conflicting snippets can shape people’s views.
For example, searching “Is [politician] good?” could pull up positive snippets, while “Is [politician] bad?” might show negative ones—even if both snippets come from the same article. This could reinforce people’s existing biases rather than providing a clear view of the facts.
Why This Matters for Everyone
While these conflicting answers might seem like a minor annoyance, they’re part of a larger problem. People turn to Google for quick, accurate answers, especially on important topics like health or current events.
If Google’s algorithm is showing different answers based on how you phrase a question, it’s hard to trust that you’re getting the full story.
Historically, Google has positioned itself as a neutral provider of information. But if its algorithms are giving biased or conflicting answers, it could affect everything from public opinion to health decisions.
This issue might erode Google’s credibility as a reliable source, especially as more people depend on quick online answers.
How Content Creators Can Avoid the Problem
The findings from this study suggest that content creators need to be extra clear and balanced in the information they publish. By crafting content that stays accurate no matter how it’s interpreted, creators can avoid having their work pulled out of context in Google’s snippets.
To monitor this, experts recommend that creators regularly check how their content appears in Google snippets. Testing different search phrases can reveal whether their content is represented accurately or if Google’s algorithm sends mixed messages.
You can use third-party SEO tools like Semrush or Ahrefs to identify the keywords that are appearing with a featured snippet result and then verify if they are being used in the right context.
What Google Has to Say
Google has acknowledged the challenge, although it defended its algorithms as “providing diverse viewpoints.” The company points to features like “About this result,” which help users verify information sources.
However, with these issues persisting, the problem appears to be more structural than Google is willing to admit. Some experts suggest that Google’s attempt to become a one-stop “answer engine” might need to take a backseat until these biases are addressed.
As AI models advance and Google shifts further into providing direct answers, it will be interesting to see if new machine-learning techniques can mitigate these contradictory snippets.
But for now, the best advice for users is to dig deeper than the first snippet or two, consult multiple sources, and always question if what we’re seeing is a reflection of the full truth or just a well-packaged assumption of what Google thinks we want to know.
Practical Tips for Getting Reliable Information on Google
Here’s what you can do to make sure you’re getting accurate information from Google:
Try Different Phrasings: Rephrase your question and see if you get conflicting answers.
Check Full Articles: Instead of just reading the snippet, click through to the full article for context.
Verify Important Facts: For major topics, use multiple trusted sources.
Beware of Biases: Remember that Google may show answers that match popular beliefs.
Stay Updated on Google Changes: As Google updates its algorithms, keep an eye on how it affects search accuracy.
Key Takeaways
- Google snippets can show opposing answers from the same source based on phrasing.
- Google’s focus on “user intent” sometimes leads to confusing, biased results.
- Google’s algorithm might reinforce existing beliefs by prioritizing certain answers.
- Conflicting snippets challenge Google’s reputation as a neutral source.
- Users should question snippets, and creators should aim for clarity.
Get Your Free SEO Audit Now!
Enter your website URL below to receive a comprehensive SEO report with tailored insights to boost your site's visibility and rankings.

You May Also Like
Google’s Tabbed Content Dilemma: Are You Losing SEO Rankings?
Website owners and digital marketers have long debated whether Google can effectively crawl and index tabbed content. Now, thanks to insights from John Mueller, we finally have some clarity—but it might not be what you expected. SEO expert Remy Sharp recently asked on Bluesky whether Google and other search engines could navigate JavaScript or CSS-based … Google’s Tabbed Content Dilemma: Are You Losing SEO Rankings?
Google’s Review Count Bug Leaves Businesses Frustrated
A strange bug has been affecting Google reviews since Friday, February 7th, causing widespread panic among small businesses and local SEO professionals. Many businesses woke up to find some of their hard-earned reviews missing, while others noticed significant drops in their review count. But before assuming the worst, here’s what’s actually happening. What’s Happening … Google’s Review Count Bug Leaves Businesses Frustrated
The Future of AI: Who Gains and Who Loses in the Tech Boom?
AI is no longer some futuristic concept; it’s here, and it’s moving fast. But as exciting as this is, OpenAI CEO Sam Altman has a big concern – not everyone is going to benefit equally. Some will ride the wave of AI into new opportunities, while others might find themselves left behind. Well, that’s a … The Future of AI: Who Gains and Who Loses in the Tech Boom?
Comments