SEO experts and digital publishers are raising concerns over a potential shift in Google’s Image Search algorithm, which may be suppressing AI-generated images. 

Recent reports from multiple website owners indicate significant drops in AI image traffic, sparking debates about whether Google is tweaking its ranking criteria to favor traditionally created visuals.

Toggle

Free SEO Audit: Uncover Hidden SEO Opportunities Before Your Competitors Do

Gain early access to a tailored SEO audit that reveals untapped SEO opportunities and gaps in your website.

Analyze My Site

A Mysterious Decline in AI Image Visibility

Zack Notes, a LinkedIn user and website owner, first highlighted this phenomenon after noticing a sharp decline in traffic to AI-generated images on his gaming website, Animal Matchup. 

While overall web traffic remained stable, the number of visitors from Google’s Image Search plummeted without any apparent site-level changes.

Following his post, other site owners came forward with similar experiences, reporting sudden drops in AI image rankings. 

Zach later added:

SEO professional Kane Jamison supported these observations, explaining:

Google’s AI Content Dilemma

Google has long emphasized “helpful, reliable, and people-first content,” without explicitly banning AI-generated materials. However, this recent trend suggests the company might be implementing undisclosed quality standards for AI images, potentially affecting visibility in search results.

This shift could be part of a broader push to ensure AI-generated images meet specific authenticity and relevance benchmarks before ranking prominently.

The Fallout for Digital Creators

For online publishers, designers, and SEO specialists who heavily depend on AI-generated visuals, this development presents an unexpected challenge. 

If Google is indeed adjusting its algorithm to deprioritize AI-generated images, digital content strategies will need to evolve to maintain engagement and visibility.

This change could encourage creators to mix AI-generated and human-made imagery to navigate potential ranking penalties. Experts suggest that quality, contextual relevance, and originality will play even greater roles in determining an image’s search ranking.

Are We Seeing a New Trend in Search Algorithms?

Google has made multiple search updates in recent months, many focusing on AI-generated content. 

The Helpful Content Update, introduced in late 2023, aimed to boost content that exhibits expertise, experience, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness (E-E-A-T). 

SEO specialists speculate that similar principles are now being applied to AI-generated images.

What Should Creators Do Next?

At this point, Google has not officially confirmed any algorithm change related to AI-generated images. 

However, content creators and marketers are closely watching the situation to understand how future updates may shape their visibility.

Experts recommend that site owners:

• Regularly track Google Search Console metrics for changes in image search performance.
• Use a combination of AI-generated and manually created images to maintain balance.
• Optimize image metadata, alt text, and captions to improve discoverability.
• Stay informed on search engine updates and refine SEO strategies accordingly.

Key Takeaways

• SEO professionals report a widespread decline in AI-generated image rankings on Google.
• Google may be refining its image search criteria to prioritize traditionally created images.
• AI images could be facing increased scrutiny under new algorithm updates.
• Creators may need to mix AI-generated and original images for better visibility.
• Google has not confirmed any official changes, but experts are monitoring the impact closely.